Of the 51 championships awarded (3 divisions each year), 26 different schools have won. St. Mary's Menomonee Falls has won 7 banners, with Holy Apostles taking home 6. Christ King has won 4 banners. Four schools have won 3 championships (St. Mary Visitation Elm Grove, St. Boniface, St. Francis Borgia, and St. Dominic), and four schools have won 2 championships (Waukesha Catholic, St. Mary's Burlington, St. Leonard, and St. Mary - Hales Corners).
2023 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. Mary - Hales Corners
Girls Division 2 - Bruce Guadalupe/Acosta
Boys Division - St. Dominic
2022 Champions
Girls Division 1 - Christ King
Girls Division 2 - St. Alphonsus/St. Matthew
Boys Division - St. Mary Visitation
2021 Champions
Girls Division 1 - Christ King/Wauwatosa Catholic
Girls Division 2 - Milwaukee Montessori
Boys Division - St. Dominic
2020 Champions
No tournament held due to Covid cancelling season
2019 Champions
Girls Division 1 - Burlington Catholic
Girls Division 2 - St. Matthew/Divine Mercy
Boys Division - Holy Apostles
2018 Champions
Girls Division 1 - Christ King - Wauwatosa
Girls Division 2 - St. John XXIII - Port Washington
Boys Division - St. Anthony on the Lake (Pewaukee)/St. Teresa (Hartland)
2017 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. Mary - Menomonee Falls
Girls Division 2 - St. Boniface - Germantown
Boys Division - St. Mary - Menomonee Falls
2016 Champions
Girls Division 1 - Waukesha Catholic - Waukesha
Girls Division 2 - St. Gabriel - Hubertus
Boys Division - Holy Apostles - New Berlin
2015 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. Mary - Hales Corners
Girls Division 2 - St. Francis Borgia - Cedarburg
Boys Division - St. Mary - Menomonee Falls
2014 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. Mary - Menomonee Falls
Girls Division 2 - St. Mary - Burlington
Boys Division - Holy Apostles - New Berlin
2013 Champions
Girls Division 1 - Christ King - Wauwatosa
Girls Division 2 - St. Francis Borgia (White) - Cedarburg
Boys Division - St. Charles - Burlington
2012 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. Mary - Menomonee Falls
Girls Division 2 - St. Peter - East Troy
Boys Division - St. Mary Visitation - Elm Grove
2011 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. John Vianney - Brookfield
Girls Division 2 - St. Boniface - Germantown
Boys Division - Holy Apostles - New Berlin
2010 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. Matthias - Milwaukee
Girls Division 2 - St. Mary - Burlington
Boys Division - St. Dominic - Brookfield
2009 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. Mary - Menomonee Falls
Girls Division 2 - St. Francis Borgia - Cedarburg
Boys Division - St. Mary Visitation - Elm Grove
2008 Champions
Girls Division 1 - Holy Apostles - New Berlin
Girls Division 2 - St. Charles - Hartland
Boys Division - St. Leonard - Muskego
2007 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. Leonard - Muskego
Girls Division 2 - St. Boniface - Germantown
Boys Division - Waukesha Catholic - Waukesha
2006 Champions
Girls Division 1 - St. Joseph - Wauwatosa
Girls Division 2 - St. James - Muskego
Boys Division - Holy Apostles - New Berlin